How to fix a confusing pricing page using a first click test

Not sure why your pricing page isn't converting? Learn how to run a first click test using a real example, so you can pinpoint exactly what's confusing users.

Share on:

Is your pricing page confusing the exact people you want to convert? If visitors can't quickly and confidently pick the right plan, they hesitate – or leave. This tutorial shows you how to diagnose exactly what's unclear using a first click test, with a real working example.

What you'll learn in this tutorial:

  • How to design a first click test that reveals pricing page confusion instead of just tracking clicks

  • How to remove prices from the test so participants evaluate plans on fit, not budget

  • How to write screener questions that get feedback from people who actually match your target customer

  • How to recruit targeted participants fast using the Lyssna panel

  • How to read agreement ratings and open-ended feedback together to find the real story behind the clicks

  • How to turn open-ended themes into specific, ship-ready copy changes

Whether you're launching a new pricing page or trying to figure out why an existing one isn't converting, this approach gives you a clear, fast way to find out what's actually getting in the way.

Key takeaway: You don't need better prices or bigger discounts to fix a pricing page that's not converting – you need to know if your plans are described in language your users actually use.

Chapters:

  • 0:00 – Introduction

  • 1:58 – What we're testing

  • 3:04 – Building the first click test

  • 8:00 – Recruiting participants

  • 9:37 – Analyzing the results

  • 13:35 – What comes next

Resources:

Every person who lands on your pricing page comes in with their own situation, their own needs, priorities, considerations, decision-making factors. A good pricing page gives them the exact information they need to make a clear, confident choice.

Now, designing a clear pricing page sounds simple, but it's a little easier said than done. If you've got multiple plans, a lot of features, different tiers for different use cases, it can get complicated really quickly.

So it's already a challenge, but then you have the added pressure of all the business goals that are impacted by it. It's a really key part of the journey. It's where users convert, upgrade. It's where they make that decision to either become a customer or to leave.

The good news is that getting your pricing page right starts with a simple foundation.

It's all about understanding your users. What are they evaluating? What are they looking for? What are they prioritizing? And what makes them feel like one of your plans is the right one for them?

In this playbook, I'm going to walk you through a step-by-step process along with a ready-to-use Lyssna research template to improve the clarity and conversions of any pricing page.

We're going to use a first click test to understand what users are evaluating, how well the page is surfacing that information, and what, if anything, is getting in the way.

So if you've got a pricing page that you want to improve, follow along.

Okay, so before we jump into the study, let's walk through the scenario that I'm going to be using for this playbook. We're going to work with a fictional company called MailKind. It's an email marketing tool for small businesses, independent creators, and people selling stuff online.

So the product is solid, but as a team, let's say we have a hunch that the pricing page could be doing a little bit more to drive some of those conversions. So we want to find out exactly where we might be able to make it better.

The problem isn't that MailKind doesn't have the features that people need. The challenge is how those features are communicated. We could come up with a lot of ideas and assumptions on how to improve it, but instead of guessing, we're going to test it.

Now, you'll notice that the pricing page I'm showing here and the one I'm going to use throughout this playbook doesn't have any prices on it. That is intentional, and I'm going to explain why a little bit later.

Let's get into the Lyssna study template.

I built this to help you do two things. First is to see what plans users are choosing . And second, and more importantly, seeing how they feel about their decision. Do they feel like it is exactly what they need or is there still some confusion and ambiguity that we need to work out?

This template is built around the MailKind example, but I'm going to walk you through each section and give you guidance on how you can adapt it to your own pricing page.

Before we get into the next section take a second to preview the study as a participant. This is a really good way to get a feel for the flow the questions that we're going to be using and the overall participant experience before we get into the details.

Alright. Let's get into how I built this study out. We're going to start with the screener survey.

A screener survey is one of the most useful tools in your toolbox as a researcher to make sure you're actually getting feedback from your target audience or your potential customers.

For this study, we've got two questions in our screener. The first is, which of the following best describes you?

And for this we're screening in only the first option, so people who are independently selling products online. Second question, how often do you send marketing emails or newsletters? For this one, we're screening in anyone who's sending at least a few times a month.

Now, when you're creating your own screener survey for your pricing page study, use this one as a starting point. Keep it brief. Keep the questions focused on your participants' behavior and their experience rather than just demographic information. And make sure that your questions and your answer choices are worded clearly enough so there's no room for confusion or bias.

After the screener, for the participants who are screened in, they are going to see a welcome message. If you're writing your own welcome message, keep it short, keep it neutral, keep it friendly, and just provide enough context for your participants to understand the expectations without giving away what you're testing or biasing them in any way.

Now we're getting into the next section.

This is the core part of our study here, the first click test. So since we already screened in people who are selling stuff online and sending a couple emails a month, we're going to give them a simple task or prompt based on their own experience.

Our question here, based on your own business and email marketing needs, which plan feels like the best fit? Take a look and click the one that you'd choose.

Now, as I've already mentioned, the prices are missing from this pricing page. That is on purpose, and here's why I did it. When participants aren't actually signing up or actually spending their own money on one of these plans, they tend to default to the most expensive plan and just kind of assume that it's going to have everything that they need.

That doesn't tell us much about whether the page is clear, whether it's easy to evaluate, or whether they're making a decision based on their own priorities. So by removing prices, we keep the participants focused on what we actually want to test for, whether the page clearly communicates enough for them to choose the right plan.

Price sensitivity is definitely worth studying and goes hand-in-hand with what we're doing here, but that is a different type of study with some different methods and different questions. This one is all about the page clarity and comprehension.

So we've got our first click test set up. That's going to show us which plans participants were selecting.

But every participant has to click on something, so that alone doesn't tell us everything that we need to know. Just because they picked a plan doesn't mean that they feel clear, confident , or ready to buy, so that's where our follow-up questions are going to come in.

First one, we've got an agreement rating.

This page gave me the information I needed to easily and confidently choose the right plan for me. This is going to help us evaluate how good or not so good they were feeling about their choice.

Next question we have is an open-ended follow-up. Please briefly explain your rating, what helped you make your choice, and was there anything missing, confusing, or hard to find? As you'll see in the results, this is where a lot of our most useful insights are going to come from.

So our study is looking good, ready to launch. Now it's time to get it in front of some participants.

In Lyssna, you can recruit participants in two different ways. You can self-recruit by sharing a link, or use the Lyssna panel, over 690,000 participants from around the world.

You can tap into that panel for quick, high-quality feedback. So that's what we're going to go with here.

Once we've selected the panel, we've got a couple more choices to make before we place our order. First one is our sample size. For this , I'm going to go with 20 participants.

That's going to be enough for a strong signal from the clicks and some solid direction from those follow-up questions. And if we want to increase that sample size, we can always place another order with the same study. So for your own studies, it's totally okay to start small with the panel and expand if you need.

Now that we've got our sample size, we just need to hone in on our target audience. As you can see here, there are a lot of filters and criteria to choose from.

You can adjust that for your own study to really narrow down on your target audience. I'm going to keep it simple and recruit small business owners in the United States and let those two screener questions do the heavy lifting on who actually gets in.

We've got our sample size and our audience criteria, we can submit the order and wait for the results to roll in.

Alright, it's been about 30 minutes and the results are in, so let's take a look.

First, we've got our first click test results. Now, you can see that the clicks are pretty much just spread across all three plans.

What it tells us is that participants weren't aligned on a clear choice of one of these plans, even when they were evaluating it based on their own similar needs. So that's a useful signal, but more important than which plan they chose or how they were spread out across the three is how they felt about their choice.

That gets us into our follow-up questions, first with our agreement rating, and you can see here that the average score was a 2.25 out of 5. So participants didn't really feel that the page helped them make a clear, confident choice.

In our 20 open-ended responses, we saw a few really clear themes come through. The biggest one, and the most frequently mentioned, was about how the features were labeled in that pricing page. These were features that were present and listed on the page, but they weren't findable in a way that users were looking for them.

So an example, we know that our participants are running small online shops, so sending confirmations and shipping updates through email is a core need. Our pricing page showed that feature, but it was called transactional emails, which is technically correct, but that label didn't really resonate or stand out to our audience.

And we could say the same thing about list segmentation. Some of our participants wanted to send different emails to different groups of customers, maybe a recent buyer versus someone who hasn't purchased something in a while. You can do that in MailKind, and the feature is right there on the pricing page, but list segmentation didn't really jump out in a way that helped them evaluate and make a clear choice. So those were some of the main, most common takeaways from this, but there were a couple other bits of feedback that came up that are worth flagging.

First one is that store integrations and e-commerce integrations were too vague. Plan 2 has a mention of being able to sell with email, but it doesn't mention how that's done.

So for sellers who already have a platform, maybe they're selling through Shopify on their own site, sell with email was way too vague, and it created some doubt about whether the plan would even work for them.

One last bit of feedback we saw throughout was related to users and the number of seats included in each plan. Several participants mentioned working with a partner or an assistant or a team, and that they needed to know how many users could log into their MailKind account and collaborate on their campaigns.

That information, like a lot of the other stuff, was actually on the pricing page, but it was buried way down in the comparison

table, and we can see that it wasn't the easiest thing to find. So taking all of that feedback into account and zooming out a little bit, we can see that the page wasn't unclear because users don't understand email marketing or because it was designed poorly. It definitely wasn't anything due to the actual prices of the plans.

It was unclear because it was written in these platform-specific internal terms that don't match how users actually think about their needs and the decisions they're making as they're going through the pricing page.

It's a good reminder that a clear, high converting pricing page, a complete pricing page, is not one that just simply lists out everything that's included in each plan.

It has to connect with your users, and it has to help someone ultimately make a choice.

The big question now is: what do we do next?

First I'd start out by renaming features to match how our users were talking about them, specifically in those open-ended questions.

So I might switch transactional emails to something like automated order confirmation and shipping emails. List segmentation might become send to specific customer groups. Same features, but now just using language that actually will land.

Next improvement I'd make is pretty straightforward, to be more specific about those e-commerce integrations. In the original one, sell with email is nice, easy to understand, but as we saw in our feedback, not specific enough to help people make a confident decision.

Finally, based on our feedback here, I'd surface that information about users and seats available for each plan a little further up and a little bit more prominently, rather than burying it all the way down in that table.

Those are a couple immediate directions that jump out to me when I think about how I'd improve this page based on the feedback. But whatever changes or improvements we wanted to make, we could easily validate them by running this exact same study again, this time with an updated redesigned page. We could see if the click pattern got more aligned, if people were selecting a similar plan for their needs.

We could see if that agreement rating went up, and we could see what people were citing in that open-ended question.

We started this video with a really common scenario and a really common challenge, a pricing page that wasn't converting as well as it should, with not a lot of insight as to why.

Instead of guessing at what would fix it, we ran a simple study, and we let users show us exactly where things were falling short.

And as you can see with some of those next steps that I outlined, the potential ways to improve this pricing page aren't complicated or super resource intensive. They just weren't visible until we put it in front of people and asked.

If you've got a pricing page that you think could be improved, grab the template linked below and use this one as a starting point for your own study.

We're putting out more research playbooks just like this one to help you do efficient, effective research, to help you make good product decisions, and to help you feel more confident n what you're building. If this was helpful, like the video, subscribe, and if you've got a pricing page that you're trying to improve or a product design research challenge that you would like to see us break down, let me know in the comments.

We might feature that in an upcoming playbook. Thanks for watching, and I'll see you in the next one.


Try for free today

Join over 320,000+ marketers, designers, researchers, and product leaders who use Lyssna to make data-driven decisions.

No credit card required

4.5/5 rating
Rating logos
unilever_dark.webpipg_dark.webpstoryblok_dark.webpasana_dark.webpmeltwater_dark.webpgodaddy_dark.webpynab_dark.webphubspot.webpeneco_dark.webpsmartsheet_dark.webpzendesk_dark.webploreal_dark.webpmiro_dark.webpairtable_dark.webpgoogle_dark.webpaesop_dark.webptripcom_dark.webpmonday_dark.webphilton_dark.webpfigma-wordmark-black.webpHubspot logounilever_dark.webpipg_dark.webpstoryblok_dark.webpasana_dark.webpmeltwater_dark.webpgodaddy_dark.webpynab_dark.webphubspot.webpeneco_dark.webpsmartsheet_dark.webpzendesk_dark.webploreal_dark.webpmiro_dark.webpairtable_dark.webpgoogle_dark.webpaesop_dark.webptripcom_dark.webpmonday_dark.webphilton_dark.webpfigma-wordmark-black.webpHubspot logo