How to test headline ideas using five second testing

Not sure which headline will resonate? This tutorial uses a real example to test headline directions with real users, so you can choose with confidence.

Share on:

A headline can be well-written and still fail to make anyone want to keep reading – because the gap between a good headline and a great one isn't clever copy, it's whether it resonates with the specific audience you're trying to reach.

What you'll learn in this tutorial:

  • How to set up a five second test to capture unbiased first impressions of a headline

  • How to structure a split test in Lyssna so each participant only ever sees one headline direction

  • How to write follow-up questions that measure relevance and surface open-ended themes

  • How to recruit targeted participants quickly using the Lyssna panel

  • How to read relevance scores alongside open-ended responses to find your strongest direction

  • How to turn your results into your next headline iteration

Whether you're a marketer trying to land on the right homepage headline or a designer validating messaging as part of a page redesign, this playbook gives you a fast, repeatable way to get the answer from your actual audience – and move forward with confidence.

Key takeaway: You don't need Don Draper-level creativity to write a winning headline – you need to put it in front of the right people and listen to what they say.

Chapters:

  • 0:00 – Introduction

  • 1:18 – What we're testing: SparkStory example

  • 3:15 – Build your study

  • 8:54 – Recruit your participants

  • 10:59 – Analyze your results

  • 14:04 – What comes next?

Resources:

A great headline does one thing: it makes you want to read the next line. That's all. That's the whole job. And while it's a simple goal, it's one of the oldest challenges in marketing.

There are some tried and true strategies for a great headline. You can lead with a pain point. You can sell a dream. You can just say exactly what the thing does. While there's no guaranteed formula to get it right, there is one factor that has the most impact, understanding your audience, knowing exactly what is going to resonate with the people you're trying to reach.

Without that, you end up tweaking, wordsmithing, second-guessing . And while that trial and error can eventually lead to a headline, there is a much better and a much quicker path. Put it in front of your audience and see how they feel.

In this playbook, I'm going to walk you through a step-by-step process along with a ready-to-use Lyssna research template to test some different headline directions with real users.

So if you are writing headlines and you've got a lot of possible ideas, directions, angles, but want to land on the one, follow along.

Before we jump into the study, let's walk through the product and the example scenario that I'll be using for this playbook. We're going to be working with a fictional company product called SparkStory. SparkStory is a tool that helps business owners, freelancers, brands, anyone who sells something easily collect, manage, and display customer reviews and testimonials on their site.

It solves a problem that so many business owners experience. You have happy customers and they let you know it in your DMs, your emails, in person after they buy something.

Basically, you have a lot of glowing reviews, but they're not showing up anywhere that new customers can see them. SparkStory fixes that. It's an all-in-one platform to take the headache out of getting reviews. No chasing down customers for testimonials, no copy-pasting, no design work involved.

So the product is solid, but the team is stuck on the homepage headline, and they've got two directions on the table.

The first headline, headline A, leads with the big pain point: for brands with happy customers who never leave reviews. This one's all about naming that exact frustration, the pain behind testimonials and reviews that a lot of business owners are probably already experiencing.

The next headline is more outcome, solution-led: glowing reviews on autopilot from customers who already love your products.

Now, both of these are well-written, viable options for a good headline.

Either of these could work. But instead of going with a gut reaction to decide between the two or just debating and brainstorming internally, we're going to test it out and see which one comes out on top.

Let's take a look at the template. Open it up, and you should see what I'm seeing here. I built this template specifically to help you learn and evaluate which headline direction lands with your target audience, what they actually take away in those first few seconds, and what their own words tell you about what to write next.

So this template is built around the SparkStory example , but I'm going to walk through each section, show you how I set it up, and give you the guidance and tips you need to adapt it to your own headline test.

Before we get into the build-out of each section, take a second to preview the study as a participant. This is a great way to get a better idea of the flow and the participant experience before we get into the details.

Let's get into the build. We're going to start off with our screener survey. So a screener survey is one of the most useful tools for making sure that you're getting feedback from the right people.

For this study, I just asked one screener question about how important reviews and testimonials are to their business. So I screened in anyone who answered very important or essential to my business, and everyone else was screened out.

Couple tips for writing your own screener survey. First, keep them brief. Second, focus on the key characteristics and the experience that you're looking for in your participants, not just basic demographic or geographic information.

Finally, make sure your screener questions and your answer choices are clearly worded, so you don't leave any room for ambiguity or bias.

Now that we've got our screener question down, let's move on to the welcome message.

A welcome message just kind of sets the tone and provides a little context before people get into the actual questions. For your welcome message, keep it short and neutral. You want to give participants a little bit of context without giving away what you're testing or biasing them in any way.

And above all, set the expectation for open and honest feedback. You want participants to feel comfortable and come in without any bias or pressure to respond a certain way.

Next, we get into the five second test, which is really the core aspect of this study. Participants get this little prompt that they'll see a homepage for five seconds and to take it in and remember as much as they can.

From there, the SparkStory landing page with one of our headlines appears, and after five seconds, it's gone. Those five seconds are going to allow participants to get a good look at the headline and the landing page, but not give them too much time to overanalyze. We're still going to be getting those first reactions to it.

For SparkStory, I uploaded a screenshot of each homepage design for headline A and headline B. After participants see that for five seconds, they're going to be thrown right into a couple follow-up questions.

First follow-up question is all about the first impression. What's your reaction to this? Briefly describe anything that stood out or what you think or feel after seeing it.

Second question is about relevance and kind of quantifying how much it connects with the participant. How relevant does this feel to your own needs or challenges in your business? And we've got a scale from one, not relevant at all, to five, extremely relevant.

So this gives us a comparable score across those two headlines.

Third and final question. When it comes to collecting reviews or testimonials for your business, do you have any frustrations or challenges with it? If so, describe them in your own words.

So we've got solid five second test and some good follow-up questions here. Now we're going to do a little work on the structure of the study, and more specifically, we're going to set this up as a split test.

So here's how it's set up in Lyssna. As you can see, we've created two identical five second tests with the exact same follow-up question. The only difference is one shows the screenshot of headline A, the other shows the screenshot of headline B.

Both of those sections are placed inside a section group, and that section group is set to random subset. Show one section to each participant.

So we've got a group with these two sections for each headline. We can see both of them, but participants are only going to see one of them. They're not even going to know the other headline exists.

This split is really important for testing the immediate reaction to a headline like this.

If a participant sees these headlines side by side, it becomes a preference test, which can be useful in its own right. But in this situation, we really want that honest first reaction, not a detailed comparison or a back-and-forth analysis of each of the headlines.

We've got our screener, our welcome message, our five second test and follow-ups, and our split test set up. Our study is looking good, so let's get into recruitment and get it in front of some participants.

In Lyssna, there are a couple ways to recruit.

You can self-recruit by creating a link and sharing that directly with your own audience, or you can use the Lyssna panel and tap into over six hundred and ninety thousand participants from around the world. I like to use the panel. It's a great way to get quick, really high-quality feedback, and there are some really good tools to zoom in on your target audience a little bit more closely.

Now, once we've opted to recruit from the Lyssna panel, there are still a couple choices to make before we submit our order and start gathering that feedback.

The first one is choosing your sample size, how many participants you want to distribute this study to. Sample size can vary depending on the type of research you're running, the specificity of your audience, and the level of confidence that you're looking for in your results. For a study like this, I'm going to go with 20 participants, which should be enough to get a strong signal and some solid direction from our scores, our split test, and some of those open-ended questions.

If we get the results back and we want to hear from more people, increase our sample size, we can always place another order in the Lyssna panel with the exact same study. So starting small with your sample size is a perfectly good approach.

Now we're going to define our target audience, who we want to invite from the Lyssna panel.

As you can see, there's a ton of criteria that you can use to drill down to your exact audience. But for this study, I'm going to keep it simple. I'm selecting business owners in the United States, and I'm going to let our screener survey do the heavy lifting on filtering in the people who care most about reviews and testimonials for their business.

Once we've got our sample size and audience criteria set, we're going to submit the order and wait for the results to roll in.

Alright. It's been about thirty minutes, and we've got twenty responses to our study. Ten who saw our headline A, ten who saw headline B. So let's get into the results and see what happened.

First, let's start by comparing the relevance scores.

So headline A, which led with that relatable pain point and sad emoji scored a point and a half higher. So even with a relatively small sample size, that's a pretty strong signal.

If we had to pick one of these two headlines right now, just based off this score, we'd go with A. But we don't have to do that, and that is not the whole story in these results.

Let's look at what each group said in their first reaction responses.

This is the question they immediately answered after seeing the headline for five seconds. So group A, the pain point-led headline, there were a lot of responses that all pretty much got to the same place of relatability.

That's me. That's my situation. That is exactly the problem that I'm facing with testimonials.

The pain of knowing that people like your product but not seeing it show up anywhere that new customers can actually see it. That clearly resonated with this group.

Going to group B, our outcome solution-led headline. This showed that people understood the product. They got what it does, and some were pretty interested in the idea of putting reviews on autopilot.

So it wasn't unclear or confusing. It just didn't create that same instant personal connection.

Now let's look at the last follow-up question, the open-ended one about challenges surrounding reviews and testimonials.

So this is where we saw much more alignment between both of these groups. No matter what headline the participants saw, there were some common themes we saw pop up here. Not having a system, feeling awkward chasing people down, reviews taking too much time and effort for not enough of a return. But there was also one theme that stood out that wasn't addressed in the headline, something new that we saw here.

It's not just hard to collect reviews, it's hard to get them displayed somewhere that future customers can actually see them. That came up consistently across both groups, totally unprompted.

So putting it all together, headline A drew people in with a specific, very relatable pain point more than the autopilot solution in headline B.

And the open-ended responses surfaced a mix of familiar pain points around reviews, plus a new, more specific one that kept coming up. Not just the challenge of collecting reviews, but getting them displayed nicely where they count.

So we've got some strong feedback, some clear standout themes, but the big question remains: where do we go from here?

If we're SparkStory, what's our next homepage headline?

Well, if we're limited to our two original choices, we'd go with A. But if we want to try to optimize further, we've got some really good material to work with. We could draft some new versions of the headline that follow that same approach, naming a specific relatable pain point, forming that instant connection with visitors.

You could run the same study, compare the current headline A to that next iteration. You could see if it moves the needle on relevance and if any new language or themes pop up in those open-end responses.

We started with a really common problem, a couple headline directions, but no clear winner.

We could have gone with our gut reaction. We could have voted on it as a team. We could definitely tweak it endlessly without any real direction, but instead we solved it with a simple study that we put in front of the right people.

Most importantly, this process of getting to a great headline did not require Don Draper-level creativity or a super novel marketing angle. It was way simpler than that.

We put it in front of our users, listened to their feedback, and used that to guide the way.

We're working on more research playbooks just like this one to help you do efficient, effective research, make better product decisions, and feel more comfortable about what you're building and the headlines you're writing.


So if this was helpful, like the video, subscribe for more, and leave us a comment. Let me know what you're working on, whether you're trying to get to the perfect headline or you've got another product research challenge that you'd like to see us break down. Tell me what's on your plate. We might feature it in an upcoming playbook.


Thanks, and see you in the next one.



Try for free today

Join over 320,000+ marketers, designers, researchers, and product leaders who use Lyssna to make data-driven decisions.

No credit card required

4.5/5 rating
Rating logos
unilever_dark.webpipg_dark.webpstoryblok_dark.webpasana_dark.webpmeltwater_dark.webpgodaddy_dark.webpynab_dark.webphubspot.webpeneco_dark.webpsmartsheet_dark.webpzendesk_dark.webploreal_dark.webpmiro_dark.webpairtable_dark.webpgoogle_dark.webpaesop_dark.webptripcom_dark.webpmonday_dark.webphilton_dark.webpfigma-wordmark-black.webpHubspot logounilever_dark.webpipg_dark.webpstoryblok_dark.webpasana_dark.webpmeltwater_dark.webpgodaddy_dark.webpynab_dark.webphubspot.webpeneco_dark.webpsmartsheet_dark.webpzendesk_dark.webploreal_dark.webpmiro_dark.webpairtable_dark.webpgoogle_dark.webpaesop_dark.webptripcom_dark.webpmonday_dark.webphilton_dark.webpfigma-wordmark-black.webpHubspot logo